Brooklyn residents, backed by political leaders, healthcare professionals, and activists, including Reverend Al Sharpton, stood united against the proposed closure of SUNY Downstate Hospital, a critical healthcare institution in the heart of East Flatbush. This predominantly Black neighborhood, already facing a healthcare access crisis, could see its situation worsen if the state’s plans come to fruition. More than just a medical facility, SUNY Downstate represents a beacon of hope and a source of life-saving services for a community where quality healthcare is scarce.
A recent poll commissioned by the American Federation of Teachers and conducted by Hart Research revealed overwhelming opposition to the closure, with over 70% of local residents rejecting the state’s plan. The poll underscores a stark reality: the proposed shutdown is not just an administrative decision but a potential health catastrophe for thousands. Central Brooklyn, described in a January state Health Department report as having “generally low” hospital quality, especially in areas with significant Black populations, stands to lose invaluable resources like the borough’s only kidney transplant program and one of two high-level perinatal care centers.
The backdrop to this outcry is a dire financial predicament, with SUNY Downstate facing a projected $100 million deficit. Governor Kathy Hochul’s administration suggests moving some patient services to Kings County Hospital as a solution. However, this proposal has met fierce resistance. Critics argue that such a move would not only fail to address the underlying issues of chronic underfunding but also further deprive an underserved community of essential healthcare services.
Reverend Al Sharpton’s involvement in the massive rally to save SUNY Downstate underscores the broader implications of the closure. Sharpton, a vocal advocate for social justice and equity, highlighted the hospital’s role as one of the few medical establishments catering to the community’s needs. “Shutting down Downstate will not be tolerated,” Sharpton declared, emphasizing the hospital staff’s heroic efforts to keep lives going with limited resources.
The state’s plan has catalyzed a significant mobilization among unions, faith leaders, and elected officials. The United University Professions, American Federation of Teachers, and other labor organizations have joined forces with Senator Zellnor Myrie, Assemblymember Latrice Walker, and a coalition of faith leaders to challenge the closure. Their opposition is rooted in a commitment to safeguarding access to quality healthcare for all, especially for Medicaid, uninsured, or underinsured patients who constitute the majority of SUNY Downstate’s clientele.
Historically, Brooklyn has witnessed the closure of five hospitals since 2003, exacerbating the healthcare access gap. The current battle over SUNY Downstate is seen not just as a fight to save a hospital but as a crusade against the systemic neglect and health disparities afflicting Black and brown communities. Public Employees Federation President Wayne Spence and AFT President Randi Weingarten have expressed their dismay, pointing out the betrayal of healthcare workers who risked their lives during the pandemic and the injustice of potentially closing a vital institution in a predominantly Black and brown community.
Governor Hochul’s office has responded by committing $400 million to modernize healthcare facilities in Central Brooklyn, insisting on not closing but revitalizing Downstate. However, this pledge has done little to quell fears, with many questioning the viability of relocating services and the potential impact on patient care quality.
As the deadline looms, the community’s resolve remains unshaken. The rallying cry to save SUNY Downstate is more than a plea for financial investment; it’s a demand for recognition, respect, and the right to health equity. It challenges the state to honor its obligations to its most vulnerable citizens, compelling leaders to wield their political power In defense of a fundamental human right: access to healthcare.
